You switch to vegan meals and feel good about your decision. Then a headline tells you that a vegan diet destroys muscle. Should you be worried?
The answer depends on what you eat, how much you eat, your age and your activity. A recent study in older adults gives us a reason to pay attention, but it does not show that every vegan diet causes muscle loss.
What did the study find?
Researchers followed 72 healthy adults aged 65 or older for 12 weeks. One group continued their usual omnivorous diet. A second group chose their own vegan meals. A third followed a vegan diet and did resistance training.
On average, the vegan group lost more thigh muscle volume than the omnivorous group. The vegan group that exercised also lost muscle volume, but less than the vegan group without training. Measures of muscle protein synthesis during the first ten days were lower in the vegan group without exercise. The study measured muscle with MRI, which makes the result worth taking seriously.
What the comparison cannot tell us
The vegan participants also reduced their protein intake and lost body weight. Participants chose their own food, so the diets were not matched for protein or energy intake. Those differences make it difficult to say what would have happened if all groups had eaten enough protein and the same amount of energy.
The study does not prove that a carefully planned vegan diet would have the same effect. Equally, it does not prove that extra protein alone would have prevented every change. We need more studies designed to answer those questions in older adults.
Can you build muscle on a vegan diet?
Yes. In another controlled study, younger adults who ate a protein rich vegan diet and followed a resistance training program gained similar amounts of muscle to participants eating an omnivorous diet with the same protein intake. That is encouraging, although results from younger adults cannot automatically be applied to everyone over 65.
Protein sources can differ in digestibility and amino acid composition. In practice, a varied vegan diet with enough total protein can help meet your needs. Some people find a protein supplement useful; others can reach their target through food.
What does this look like at dinner?
Imagine a plate of rice and vegetables. It can be a good meal, but it may not contain much protein. Add tofu or tempeh, or use lentils or beans as a substantial part of the meal. Soy yogurt, soy milk and other protein rich foods can help across the rest of the day.
Look at your usual meals before you make dramatic changes. Is there a meaningful source of protein at breakfast, lunch and dinner? If not, choose one meal and make an adjustment you would enjoy repeating.
How much protein do you need?
Needs vary with age, health, body size and activity. People who exercise or are losing weight may benefit from more protein than the general minimum. A range around 1.2 to 1.6 grams per kilogram of body weight per day is often discussed for active people, but it is not an essential minimum for everyone. For a person weighing 70 kg, that range would be about 84 to 112 grams per day.
If you are older, have kidney disease or another medical condition, or are unsure how much food you need, discuss your situation with your clinician or a registered dietitian. A vegan diet also needs a reliable source of vitamin B12, along with attention to other nutrients depending on the foods you choose.
Protecting muscle while losing weight
Resistance training, adequate protein and a manageable calorie deficit can help you retain muscle while you lose weight. Your training might start with exercises at home, machines at the gym or another approach suited to your abilities. The useful plan is one you can continue.
If you realise your current meals are low in protein, you do not have to rebuild your diet in a day. Choose one meal, add a source you like and see how it works. Then repeat or adjust.
Studies: Randomized trial in older adults and Protein rich vegan and omnivorous diets during resistance training.
Practical help with weight loss and maintenance
If you want to work on cravings, emotional eating and habits you can keep, explore my course on weight loss without emotional eating. For individual coaching, contact me at +40 752 578 044.
You can also read Lose It. Keep It Off. Live It., explore How to Do Hard Things: The Discomfort Trap, or listen on Kobo and Spotify.
Costin Liculescu
Mindset Over Menu